As indicated in the previous post, cosmotheandrism follows in the footsteps of Aquinas in affirming that creation is continuous. However, we needn’t appeal to a 13th century padre in order to know this, rather, to a 20th century patent office clerk, in that we now know that the Cosmos itself is a creatively evolving event. Matter itself has an intrinsic history that must be taken into account in order to understand it: it is both in and of time, but also beyond time in the sense that it is embedded in the rationally intelligible structures that transcend it.
Nor does the Cosmos contain its sufficient reason within itself. To be sure, it is rationally ordered, but only to the extent that it is dependent upon, and thus related to, a transfinite ground or Gödelian meta-level. These upper storeys cannot go on forever, any more than causes in the past can go on forever without arriving at an uncaused cause.
Thus, at the top end of the upper vertical is what we might call the Unexplained Explanation, or O. We can never arrive at this final (ultimate) explanation, but it explains (via ultimacy) why explanations exist at all. We dwell on the subjective horizon that is always open to what is beyond ourselves, so we are at once limited forms open to the limitless. In cosmotheandric terms, being is always open to beyond-being, hence all the surprises, e.g., scientific breakthroughs, artistic creations, and evolutionary leaps.
Somewhat like AI, the Cosmos is ready to answer all our questions, but we have to furnish the correct prompts. Within it there is a multitude of orders, from mathematical to linguistic to genetic to aesthetic, so watch your prompts. If you restrict yourself to just one way of looking at things, the Cosmos will look back in only one way. Cosmic and anthropic rationality are bound inseparably together, not in any static, linear, or monocausal way, rather, in an open and dynamic manner: both Cosmos and Anthropos are events related to the Big Event of O.
Cosmotheandrism could hardly be less fashionable in a western world that has come to reject all metanarratives, which has resulted in the decomposition of reality into a tribal multiverse of subjectivism, relativism, and infrarational ideological pettiness. But it also rejects the other extreme of an absolute absolutism that imprisons us in some other guy’s static metanarrative, whether religionist or scientistic. Rather, one might say that there is an absolute metanarrative, except that it is always being written.
Have you ever watched a TV series in which the writers have written themselves into a corner? The writing might be quite clever, but it takes a lot of creativity to find a plausible way forward for the characters. Many of the narratives in which we enclose ourselves are like this, for example, the scientific narrative that ends up damming curiosity and blocking vertical progress, but also religionist ones that eliminate vertical options (e.g., predestination or divine omnipotence). Such restricted narratives inevitably generate anomalies, contradictions, and eventually absurdities, which are either ignored or papered over with ad hoc explanations.
As we have seen, both monism and dualism paint us into an existential corner that can only be escaped via trialism. For cosmotheandrism the One and the Two are always related via the Three. This is not just a Christian thing, for Lao Tse was certainly on the case in affirming that
The Tao gives birth to One. / One gives birth to Two. / Two gives birth to Three. / Three gives birth to all things.
If this isn’t revelation per se, then it is what I would call a pretty, pretty good guess. There are also echoes of this principle in Vedanta, what with the conception of God as Satchitananda, or Being-Consciousness-Beatitude. With a little metaphysical tweaking, it is not difficult to conceive of Sat as corresponding to the Absolute Father, or source and ground; Chit to the Logos-Son; and Ananda to the vivifying Holy Spirit coursing within and between.
But to repeat: we do not intend to use this or that religion to prove cosmotheandrism, rather, we want to look into how this or that religion is a more or less adequate expression of cosmotheandrism — in which God, man, and Cosmos are mutually related.
Here arises a Big Problem, for in the traditional view, we are related to God but God has no “real relations” with us. But as per Axiom 4, this is an irreducibly relational Cosmos that gives rise to irreducibly relational beings open to an irreducibly relational Godhead. The relations start at the top and filter down from there.
In Vedanta, God — or Brahman — is said to be an immutable “one without a second,” which is understandable. But for Christianity it is downright inexcusable to say that God is impassive and lacking in real relations, since that is precisely what God is: an eternally dynamic substance-in-relation. Here again the question is not whether Christianity can be reconciled with the nondualism of Vedanta, rather, whether there is an interpretation of Vedanta (or any other religion) that more adequately expresses the truth of cosmotheandrism.
For nearly all of our competitors there is a non-reciprocal arrow of dependence between creation and Creator: the former is utterly dependent on the latter, but the Theos is independent of everything. Anthropos too is necessarily dependent upon and thus related to Theos, but God does not return the favor because he cannot return the favor. If he could, then he wouldn’t be God, since God is necessarily unaffected by anything. As they say, no number of beings adds any more to Being, so God + world adds nothing to God. Cosmos cannot exist without Theos, but Theos can easily exist without the hassle of a Cosmos, much less the nuisance of the Anthropos.
This is all very neat and tidy, but is it true? Certainly not for cosmotheandrism, since our first principle is an Absolute whose immediate entailment is an Infinitude to which it is necessarily related. Traditionalists will sometimes use the analogy of the sun, which is unaffected by anything its rays happen to illuminate. Except in reality the rays are — obviously — still the sun. It is we who draw the distinction between sun and rays, whereas from the perspective of the sun — or God — they must be “not two.” They are at once distinct but of the same substance. And think of all the transformations of this substance as it embarks on an infinite journey away from its center. In this context, what is photosynthesis, for example, but an adventure of light into biology — a transformation of the sun into organisms? And supposing this has happened to the rays, one cannot say it hasn’t happened to the sun itself.
Our competitors should either stop using this analogy or get with the program and recognize what it actually implies: that life on earth is utterly dependent upon the sun, but that the sun isn’t as independent of the earth as you might imagine. Besides, in this post-Einsteinian universe, every time I do so much as a push-up I am essentially bench-pressing the earth. True, my gravitational effect on the earth is small but it is not non-existent. In reality there is always a mutual attraction within the field of gravity, and also in the field between Theos and Anthropos.
So God is a little attracted to you?
He must be, or he wouldn’t be God — at least not the God of cosmotheandrism. Besides, what is all this “God is love” business? Supposing he is, then, in the words of Bo Diddley, who do you love?
Whom.
Or better, Who, Whom, and Relation, none conceivable without the others.
Let me tell you a little story. It’s from the Rg Veda, which, in contemplating the beginning of the beginning, points out that there was neither existence nor non-existence.
What’s left?
Not even nothing, since that would presuppose something. So, “What stirred? When?” It seems that “Desire came upon that one in the beginning,” but I think you will agree that this is entirely ad hoc and explains nothing — that something that doesn’t even exist began to have desires? You can do better than that. Then again,
Who really knows? Who will here proclaim it? Whence was it produced? Whence is this creation? The gods came afterwards, with the creation of the universe. Who then knows whence it has arisen…. In the highest heaven, only he knows — or perhaps he does not know.
Well, we know, because creation is not something that ever began, nor is it something that ever ends — more like rays proceeding from the sun, which embark upon an ever-expanding journey across the Cosmos, meeting different fates along the way.
Do they ever return home?
No, because since they exist in a relational field, they never really left home anyway.








