Thursday, November 19, 2026

Monopolies & Triopolies on Truth

Perhaps we should officially designate Sunday as Rabbit Hole Day, in which we take a side-trip into areas not covered in the Trilogy, this post being an example.

We have already discussed the problem with monopolar theories of the divine, which essentially split the Theos down the middle and elevate one side over the other — for example, immutability over change, thus resulting in an eternal monotony and endless monologue. Cosmotheandrism rejects any kind of divine monad that leaves the Cosmos and Anthropos out of the Theos, or a static dualism that leaves the Theos out of the Anthropos and Cosmos. God is not just transcendent (as in deism) or immanent (as in pantheism), but always both.

As mentioned the other day, one reason I can’t find my way to the end of the book is that I keep running into thinkers who can contribute to the polyphonic trialogue of cosmotheandrism, in this case a fella’ by the name of Grigory Pomerants, who was a Soviet dissident and wide-ranging unconventional pneumanaut. He came to my attention in a book by media ecologist Andrey Mir called Postjournalism and the Death of Newspapers. Nowadays the economic model of the postjournalistic media requires them to abandon any semblance of objectivity for the manufacture of anger and polarization. We won’t get into the entire argument, but in the book there is a single quote by Pomerants to the effect that

The Devil is born from the foam at the mouth of an Angel fighting for a sacred, just cause. Everything turns to ash — people, systems, but eternal is the spirit of hatred in a fight for a just cause. Because of that, evil knows no end. Ever since I understood that, I believe that the style of polemic is more important than its subject. The subjects change but the styles form civilizations.

“That’s an interesting take,” I thought to myself, because it is similar to the cosmotheandric take on politics, even though I would prefer to keep politics out of the book, except implicitly. In other words, supposing the immutable and ironyclad Axioms of cosmotheandrism, then a certain understanding of politics necessarily follows, and it will certainly not consist of Angelic intelligences spitting in rage at the stubborn, greedy, and ignorant Devils who are willfully standing in the way of bringing about heaven on earth.

Rather, we agree with Polanyi, who characterizes secular revolutionaries as people filled with religious passion while devoid of religious constraint — for example, thou shall not lie, steal, or murder. For our friends on the other side of the cosmic aisle, we can attain heaven on earth except it will require some mixture of lyin’, theivin’, and killin’.

So I asked Gemini: Who is this guy, and could he possibly have anything to contribute to the cause of cosmotheandrism? Note the similarity to Polanyi, for Pomerants is critiquing “any ideological or religious fanaticism born from self-righteous certainty.” In his view, “evil rarely begins as a desire to do bad; it begins when ‘champions of good’ become so intoxicated by their own righteousness that they dehumanize their opponents.”

In olden times religionism was mostly responsible for this, while nowadays it is ideological ismism, which is again religious energy devoid of religious constraint. Thus Pomerants is describing a more timeless temptation, “a universal psychological and historical trap that applies equally to religious zealots and secular revolutionaries.” For him, “a crusader or inquisitor spitting in rage for God is indistinguishable from a commissar doing the same for the proletariat.” Being that he spent some unplanned time in Club Gulag, he

saw firsthand how the pursuit of a "secular paradise" justified mass terror. At the same time, he noticed that some fellow anti-Soviet dissidents could fall into the same trap of moral absolutism and intolerance.

In such circumstances it takes a big man to see the bigger picture — that the people who want to free you from one Gulag want to place you in another, but there are some countries such as Poland who lost World War II twice, having been liberated from National Socialist tyranny in exchange for for International Socialist tyranny.

But Pomerants did not reject religion, only religionism, for “Later in life he developed a profound, personal spirituality” and came to believe “that a spiritual dimension was essential to keep the human soul free from state tyranny.” That sounds very cosmotheandrish. Tell us more.

Pomerants studied Oriental philosophy, Christian mysticism, and Russian religious thought (especially Dostoevsky), yet he refused to belong to any single church or denomination. He famously wrote that he was less interested in "keepers of the sacred fire" (institutional religion) than in individuals who could "ignite this fire anew" through personal, inward searching.

It reminds me of a seething response I once received from a religionist during an internet food fight. He was getting a little suspicious and confronted me with the question of whether I was even Christian, to which I responded “Of course. And more!” But for him, there is no more. He was unaware of the cosmotheandric principle that no religion is the Absolute per se, rather, only points to it in a more or less adequate way. Which secular folk do as well, insofar as they conflate ultimacy and ultimate. Avoiding this error requires a little thing called cosmotheandric irony — the irony that will “save the world,” to put it ironically.

And guess what:

For Pomerants, true faith was marked by humility, irony, and openness — the exact opposite of the "spitting rage" of the fanatic.

You will notice that humility and openness automatically engender irony, because we know before we begin that we cannot enclose the world in a model of the world, so who can be so fundamentally unserious as to take himself seriously? I won’t bother to dredge up all the aphorisms going to this, because they number in the hundreds if not thousands.

To doubt progress is the sole progress.

In a complex system ordered to its telos, progress takes care of itself, so mind your own isness.

Impartiality is less attractive than the partiality that views itself with irony.

Of course I am partial to cosmotheandrism, but I don’t worship it. I don’t rent it shoes, and I’m not buying it a fucking beer.

God is the transcendental condition of the absurdity of the universe.

If the Cosmos contained its own sufficient reason, it would not be absurd and we would be screwed.

Ridicule is the supreme tribunal in our earthly condition.

One can bypass this tribunal if one first laughs at oneself.

Two hundred years ago it was legitimate to have confidence in the future without being totally stupid.

Who can believe in today’s plans and predictions, since we are living in the splendid future that has been planned for us every two years? According to my watch, LBJ’s war on poverty should have been won decades ago, and Obamacare means that we all have unlimited access to affordable healthcare.

Everything seems chaotic to us except our own disorder.

Just because you can’t fix your own life, it doesn't mean you can't wreck someone else’s. The first and last temptation of the progressive ideologue.

Idealism is an embarrassed theology.

There is no one more dangerous than a mob of immature idealists of all ages promising free everything and calling it democracy. Which it is, good and hard.

Liberal, democratic, progressive views gallop through history leaving a trail of torched civilizations.

Yes, but mostly peaceful torching.

In the incoherence of a political constitution lies the only real guarantee of freedom.

Freedom survives not with power but, as the framers knew, in the interstices between powers.

Christ himself is the unsurpassable King of All Irony, but that is the mother of all rabbit holes, so perhaps we can return to that subject at a later time.

At any rate, from Pomerants I was tipped off to Mikhail Bakhtin, a name I had heard of but never followed up on, and “his entire philosophy of language, dialogue, and ethics stands as a profound critique of ideological absolutism.” And “At the heart of Bakhtin’s thought is dialogism and polyphony — the idea that truth is not a single, top-down system held by one authority, but an ongoing, open-ended conversation among many independent voices.”

That’s you, dude!

Yes, except we would rebrand it as the dynamic trialogism of the Cosmic Area Rug, endlessly woven from the top-down and bottom-up. For which reason

The world is explicable from man; but man is not explicable from the world. Man is a given reality; the world is a hypothesis we invent.

Or better, “the world” is always at the intersection of Cosmos, Theos, and Anthropos, so cosmotheandrism has a triopoly on truth.

Nevertheless and allthemore,

The first step of wisdom is to admit with good humor that there is no reason why our ideas should interest anyone.

No comments:

Theme Song

Theme Song