Did you hold that thought, as instructed?
Yes, right here in my breast pocket: the final cause of the immanent universe is an intelligent being open to the Absolute, but is the Absolute open to us?
In order to address this question, let’s first call upon an obscure cosmotheandric forerunner, a 19th century freelancer named Jules Lequier, whom I discovered via Charles Hartshorne’s Philosophers Speak of God. Lequier’s own works are easy to come by, except they will set you back $1,440.27.
Lequier was an advocate of dynamic omniscience, which makes far more sense than the traditional static kind we have been critiquing. In the case of the latter, God knows from all eternity everything that has happened, is happening, and will happen, which not only results in the complete negation of anthropic freedom, but renders our existence utterly superfluous.
Bumps on God’s aseity.
Correct. Even if you choose to believe in this kind of divine omniscience, you’re just fooling yourself, since your choice has already been made before you make it. But only if choices are genuinely free can they even be called choices. For Lequier, God can know all about our choices, but not before they actually exist. Thus
it is necessary to recognize that either God in his relationship to the world contracts a new mode of existence which participates in the nature of the world, or else this world is before God as though it did not exist.... God, who sees these things change, changes also in beholding them (emphasis mine).
This is a core claim of cosmotheandrism: that the Theos is intimately related to, and involved with, what he has brought about, which is to say, Cosmos and Anthropos.
Now, anyone who knows what God is knows that God cannot be reduced to a finite human conception, so why conceptualize him as immutable? According to the analogy of being — which we endorse wholeheadedly — any similarity we posit between creation and Creator must involve an even greater dissimilarity. If traditionalists want to insist that God is analogous to an unchanging object, then it follows that he must be even more disanalogous.
Fundamentalist (or fideist) types will say that revelation is given to us precisely because the fallen human being is such a deplorable brainwreck. We can’t really understand it, rather, only submit to it and tell our stupid brains to STFU. The best we can do is repeat the Homer prayer: Lord help me, I’m just not that bright!
Cosmotheandrians fully agree that humility in these matters is not only admirable but absolutely necessary. But if one takes it too far, then out with the bathwater of pride go the babies of metaphysics, natural theology, and intelligibility more generally. Moreover, a hypertrophied humility can redound to metaphysical switcheroo, such that it becomes its own kind of pride: a theological humble brag. Folks like Luther and Calvin will say good riddance to the presumptions of reason, but neither man was what we would call a shrinking violet, hesitant to tell others how to think and what to believe.
The influential Protestant theologian Karl Barth went so far as to say that the analogy of being is an invention of the Antichrist. Rather, revelation is totally sufficient unto itself: for our part we are limited to all faith and no reason.
But where in revelation does it make the totalitarian claim that revelation is totally sufficient unto itself and that we shouldn’t even try to make intellectual sense of it?
Nowhere.
Also, once intellect is severed from the divine, this clears the field for a hostile takeover by the forces of secularism, scientism, materialism, and other ideologies. Thus, the intellect is eliminated at one end, only to return in a sharply diminished mode through the back door, and here we are.
Besides, if Christ is the Logos — the very principle and Light of intellection — and we participate in him, then the point is not to stop thinking but to begin thinking rightly and brightly.
Moreover, Christ wasn’t altogether exhaustive in his teachings, and he even said so: I still have many things to say to you, but don’t worry, because the Spirit will guide you into all truth.
Also, if we take scripture entirely literally and without the use of analogy, how could it even be intelligible? Jesus is a door. A vine. A shepherd. Heaven is a mustard seed. A wedding banquet. A treasure hidden in a field. An expensive pearl. If Jesus isn’t speaking analogously, then that’s quite a concrete jumble.
Above we floated the idea that God takes a risk, both with creation in general and with the Incarnation in particular. By which we mean “risk,” i.e., analogously.
Ironically.
But one of the unavoidable risks, it seems, is the possibility of evil and suffering. For cosmotheandrism God is not directly responsible for these, rather, only for the inherent riskiness of creation.
Analogously, supposing I will a child into existence, I assume the risk that he may turn out to be a sociopath, a drug addict, or even a Democrat. Likewise, supposing God is responsible for water, this does not imply that he wills drowning. Rather, that’s one of the risks entailed in the existence of the water we need in order to exist at all.
Now, the biggest risk of all must be the creation of creatures with free will — with the freedom to reject or even oppose the will of their Creator. But what’s a parent to do? Tommy’s a bad kid, he’s a bad seed. Why not shoot him?
That wouldn’t be a bad idea.
Oh, I’m sorry I said that. I didn’t mean to say that. I — I just mean that humans are really annoying. You know, uh, I just, uh, I need help. God, help me, please, you know.
Don’t worry, God has a plan. Or, to speak analogously, a “plan.” While it resembles the sorts of plans we make, the dissimilarities must again dwarf the similarities, even to an infinite degree.
Which is why the cosmotheandrian cringes when, in response to a horrific tragedy, some well-meaning believer blithely says It’s all a part of God’s plan, or Don’t worry, God is in control. Easy for them to say, but would you say this to a person whose house is on fire? Or grab a hose?
Likewise, no offense, but if the plan you enacted included the Holocaust, of what use was the plan?
Yeah. That’s a great plan, Bob. That’s fucking ingenious, if I understand it correctly. That’s a Swiss fucking watch.
Ricky Gervais tells a story about a man meeting God and telling him a Holocaust joke. God is offended and says That’s not funny, to which the man responds, I guess you had to be there.
So, let’s start over from the ground up. Not with a new God, but certainly a new theodicy. For example, one involving the risk that the very same God-given abilities that allow us “to enjoy literature, mathematics, science, philosophy, and all other human pursuits — gives us the capacity to formulate and carry out genocidal plans” (Hasker).









No comments:
Post a Comment