Cosmotheandrism promises three times the metaphysical fun, since it gives us the transcendent Theos above, the immanent one below, and the relational one within, even while being the same One.
Josef Ratzinger — not exactly a lightweight — articulates the final Axiom of cosmotheandrism in affirming that personhood “must be understood as relation,” this because
the three persons that exist in God are in their nature relations. They are, therefore, not substances that stand next to each other, but they are real existing relations, and nothing besides. In God, person means relation. Relation, being related, is not something superadded to the person, but it is the person itself. In its nature, the person exists only as relation.
Bishop Robert Barron says something quite similar, describing a “revolution in theology brought about by the doctrine of the Trinity” whereby “relationality gains a much stronger place in the doctrine of God”:
Whereas the classical philosophers tended to make self-subsistence the quality of ultimate reality, and relationality a quality of created being, the doctrine of the Trinity compels us to say that ultimate reality is itself characterized by relationship.... Something like ‘being toward another’ belongs to the very essence of God.
A second consequence of this revolution is that “the division between unity (God) and plurality (creatures) is radically reworked,” which brings to mind Norris Clarke’s The One and the Many, the title alluding to one of the fundamental and enduring problems of philosophy. Well, problem solved, because the plurality is always in the oneness, and vice versa. The triune Godhead “has room for plurality without in any way negating divine unity,” showing that “something like plurality obtains within absolute being. The creative ground of all existence is, in its innermost nature, a looking toward, a being toward another.”
Plurality is therefore not a fallen state or contingent accident, rather, a divine perfection, so long as its intrinsic relationality is not forgotten. Moreover, in the triune Godhead, “something like speaking to, communicating with, belongs to the ground of reality.”
Which means we can check language off our list of mysteries, even while making it no less mysterious. For “It follows that divine communication or communication with creatures is not the beginning of divine communion and communication.” In other words, man, upon awakening to manhood, enters a conversation that is always already taking place. Language itself is possible only because the Cosmos is already a conversation.
Thus communication — or dia-logos — between Persons has literally been going on forever, so the Godhead never stops partaking in the joy of communication. Which perhaps explains why we ourselves enjoy vibing with others and being deeply understood. Communication isn’t just a tool we invented to trade information, rather, an echo of the eternal joy within the Godhead. We like being understood because we are made in the image of an Eternal Understanding.
Sub-cosmotheandrians think of relation in exterior terms only, like billiard balls bouncing off one another. However, with the triune Godhead we are talking about talking-about — about irreducible intersubjectivity and co-inherence. And this co-inherence goes all the way down, even unto a quantum realm that is likewise substance (particles) in relation (field).
With this metaphysical revolution the problem of persons is also solved, but again, without rendering our personhood any less mysterious. With any luck, I will always remain a mystery to myself, but now I at least know why: because I co-inhere not only with an Other who is within me (more on which as we proceed), but with the Absolute and Infinite Other(s).
Certainly this explains all the endless intelligibility packed into being and just waiting to be understood by us: it is “Because all things are made through the Logos, which is itself nothing but a subsistent relation to the other, coinherence, and not substance or individuality, must be the basic truth of things” (Clarke).
Because intellect and being are not externally related, but rather, coinhere, we have the great privilege of potentially understanding All There Is To Know About All There Is. We know we are intellectually related to a world that intelligibly relates to us, the question being — or no longer being — how this relatedness relates to a relational Godhead.
∞
Downshifting gears for a moment, man is both conscious (like animals) but also self-conscious, or conscious of consciousness. Now, this greater consciousness of which we are conscious goes to the Other alluded to above, for it is very much as if our conscious mind is in a dialectical relationship with some sort of infinite and inexhaustible ocean of consciousness. Not to pull rank on you, but this is the whole premise of Bionian psychoanalytic psychotherapy, which takes place between the poles of O, patient, and therapist.
At first blush it appears that with self-consciousness we are somehow above or outside the unconscious Other. But this can’t be the case, for there can be no strict line between consciousness, unconsciousness, self-consciousness, because each is but a mode of relational consciousness as such. As in the Godhead, they are at once distinct but inseparable.
Early psychoanalytic models posited a sharp division between conscious and unconscious minds. However, later developments emphasized the unity of a self that always partakes of both. We can talk about the two as if they are separate, but they can’t be. Rather, it is more like the yin-yang symbol of the Tao, in which there is unconsciousness in every act of consciousness, and vice versa. Nothing good ever comes of pretending our little ego could ever drink the ocean on which it floats.
Here again, the unconscious/conscious system is analogous to the wave/particle distinction in quantum physics: a particular thought is the precipitate of a wavelike flow of consciousness, in which our conscious mind is analogous to an ocean current, an explicate pattern within the implicate ocean. One might say we are children at play along the infinite shore where the waves of eternity break upon the sands a’ time.
Sometimes we can take an idea too far, other times not far enough. To be on the safe side I like to go with the former, because only if we go too far can we recognize the far enough.
Is it going too far to suggest that there is something analogous to the conscious/unconscious distinction in God? Well, supposing the Anthropos is the image of the Theos, then perhaps our conscious/unconscious structure is a distant echo of what goes on in the Godhead. For again, we are the way we are because the Godhead is the way it is.
Having said that, we must amend our understanding of the unconscious, because there is nothing UN- about it — as if it connotes ignorance or privation. Rather, it is more like a supra- or hyper-consciousness — like the total implicate field as opposed to a particulate point of individual selfhood.
The psychoanalyst James Grotstein elevated the concept of the unconscious from its unfortunate reduction to a mere cauldron of uncivilized desires and impulses to its true place as a mysterious “alter-ego, or ‘stranger within’ that shadows our existence in a most intimate, creative, and mysterious way.” Far from being “primitive and impersonal,” our Interior Stranger is not an it but a thou: it is “subjective and ultra-personal,” a “mystical, preternatural, numinous second self” characterized by “a loftiness, sophistication, versatility, profundity, virtuosity, and brilliance that utterly dwarf the conscious aspects of the ego.”
Which is precisely what we mean by the interior Other with whom we are always engaged: there is the local or surface ego dialectically related to the ineffable subject of being, and the creative resonance between them.
Grotstein appreciates the spiritual implications of this dialectic as it manifests in our moment-to-moment experience. Otherwise, it’s a little like living your life in a tiny boat and never looking around to appreciate the immense ocean upon which your vessel is floating, and of which it is actually composed, because in reality there is again no radically separate “ego” and “unconscious,” rather, a dynamic and fruitful relation between them. The unconscious is not unconscious at all, just not fully available to the ego; obviously, the totality of nonlocal consciousness cannot be circumscribed by the local ego. Indeed, Grotstein conceptualized the unconscious as a sort of “handicapped god”—
Please, the preferred nomenclature is a differently abled god.
Right. This differently abled “unconscious” intelligence requires a partner in order to accomplish its mission, which is very similar to McGilchrist’s analogy of the RH Master and the LH Emissary. The goal of psychotherapy is not merely knowledge of, or insight into, the unconscious, rather to establish a dynamic collaboration between the phenomenal ego — our conscious self — and the “ineffable subject of being” (O) upon which the ego floats and into which it infinitely extends.
Through a creative resonance between these two aspects or poles of our being, we are more spontaneously alive, creative, and “present.” It is like adding another dimension (or two or three) of both depth and height to our being, through which we become something that has never actually been, but is somehow more real than what we presently are. In this ceaseless dynamic, a new entity emerges, a “transcendent subject” that lives harmoniously in the dialectical space between our foreground self and the mysterious background subject that surrounds and vivifies it.
For example, Eckhart wrote that “In my birth all things were born, and I was the cause of myself and of all things... And if I did not exist, God would also not exist.” Just what did he mean by this? In fact, it was something similar to Grotstein’s description of the background subject of ineffable being. That is, the God that we can know cannot exist without our first “conceiving” and giving birth to him — God needs our assistance, or cooperation, to manifest herebelow.
In Eckhart’s understanding of the Incarnation, God is eternally taking on human nature, not just once, but for all time, in the ground of our being. Eckhart adheres to the ancient Christian idea that God becomes man so that man may become God — not literally, but in Grotstein’s sense of transforming the ineffable, nonlocal God-beyond-being into a local manifestation of his presence.
Think, for example, of the production of a dream, which for Grotstein “is a unique and mysterious event, an undertaking that requires an ability to think and to create that is beyond the capacity of conscious human beings.” “[D]reams are, at the very least, complex cinematographic productions requiring consummate artistry, technology, and aesthetic decision making…” They “are dramatic plays that are written, cast, plotted, directed, and produced and require the help of scenic designers and location scouts, along with other experts…” Who is this Dreamer who dreams the dream? It is a “profound preturnatural presence whose other name is the Ineffable Subject of Being, which itself is a part of a larger holographic entity, the Supraordinate Subject of Being and Agency.”
The point is, the unconscious Dreamer who dreams the dream possesses powers that surpass what our conscious minds can bring about. Moreover, the creative person is not only like this Dreamer, but essentially harnessing the power of the Dreamer to help dream creative productions, from poems to paintings to symphonies.
Some folks get — and live — this cosmotheandric way of life, such as the producer Rick Ruben or pianist Keith Jarrett. Jarrett is famous for his marathon flights into spontaneous composition, for which he takes no credit. Rather, “I believe in Music to the extent that it was here before we were…. I don’t believe that I can create, but that I can be a channel for the Creative. I do believe in the Creator,” who we might say is the differently abled God who needs a little help from Jarrett. Likewise Ruben, who has essentially compared himself to midwife assisting the birth of a hoped-for sonic miracle that is then offered to back to God.








