Lately I’ve been inundated by so much new information—
You’ve lost the plot.
Is it that obvious? I’ve been trying to work it into the text on the fly instead of properly integrating it beforehand. Perhaps I should save the new writ for a different project and just get on with this one as it was written. You know what they say: chase two rabbit holes, enter none.
Cosmotheandrism is already the mother of all rabbit holes, since each of our three terms — Cosmos, Anthropos, Theos — partakes of Infinitude. Which is why, in the words of Chesterton, You cannot have a conversation about anything unless you are prepared to have a conversation about everything. Thus, one must be prepared to have a conversation about everything, even while knowing in advance that such a conversation — or in this case, book — is literally endless. Therefore, in order to end the book, I must set some artificial limits on it: the best we can do is make it consistent, never complete.
Which goes to our next subject, open theology. It is not so much that cosmotheandrism is a form of open theology, because theology as such — as is true of any -ology — is always already open. This follows Axiom 3, which, to repeat, goes like this:
Anthropos, Cosmos, and Theos are all open to each other and within themselves. For example, humans are open to the Cosmos, to each other, and to the Theos. The Cosmos is open to us and to something transcending it. The Godhead is open to the Cosmos and Anthropos, but also within itself, in that it is related to its own Other, even absent the creation. The Anthropos is the link between appearances and reality, or between intelligence and intelligibility, which reduces to an all-pervasive Logos, which is why being and truth constitute an endless dia-logos: intelligence and intelligibility co-inhere in the Logos that illuminates the space between immanence and transcendence. Human beings are constantly attending and responding to a spectrum of information that is somehow embedded in being and “radiates” outward and inward (into us).
Which is precisely why everything is a rabbit hole unless one encloses being in a restricted concept, or in other words, confines the endless -ology to a static -ism.
There are many reasons to believe in open theology, the most important being that without it we are screwed. For one thing, if the Theos is literally immutable and omnipotent then everything is predetermined from all eternity. Which ends in the reductio ad absurdum of Calvin—
Nasty man.
Yes, a paragoon of anti-cosmotheandrism, but hardly the only one. He insisted that the elect are elected before the game of creation even commences. Since all the power is vested in God, there is literally nothing we can do to become one of these lucky bastards. Rather, we are ontological NPCs who serve no purpose but to be furniture in a pointless dream of creation. Frankly we aren’t even a Who, just a Whom. Always the anvil, never the hammer.
Surely God can do better than Lenin?
In such a ridiculous scenario there is no way to even find out whether we are a hellbound NPC, nor any way to remedy the situation anyway, since God’s will is God’s will, and that’s final. God does not change because he cannot change. Which seems an absurd limitation on what God can and cannot do. It makes life even more kafkaesque than Kafka imagined it to be, because waking up to find ourselves transformed into a giant insect is no different from waking up and finding ourselves to be human.
The point is that there are two kinds of existentialism: atheistic and theistic. But the theistic version isn’t even really theistic if it is totally wrong about the nature of God. Rather, it’s just existentialism with a side order of idolatry.
Which is why cosmotheandrism is quintessentially open, because the alternative is absurd.
But you — or Dávila rather — said that God is the transcendental condition of the absurdity of the universe.
That was to make the ironic point that genuine absurdity is contingent — or parasitic — upon what is not absurd, rather, intelligible. The fake kind of absurdity takes itself as its own standard, resulting an an absurd reason for believing our condition to be absurd.
Open theology envisions a Theos who is both first cause and first effect, and why not? Think of the Trinity, in which we see a kind of “first cause” (in a manner of speaking) in the Father, and a “first effect” in the Son, only occurring in eternity rather than time. But because the Godhead is also First Effect, this makes it the paradigm of all open systems: it makes the Godhead irreducibly relational — which is to say affected by the Other — always giving and receiving.
Who and Whom.
Correct. This is in contrast to the totally static, immutable, and impassive God of classical theism, to whom it is difficult to relate. That is to say, we can relate to him but he cannot relate to us, and what kind of relationship is that? I am hardly the first to notice that an absolutely immutable God is a Greek import developed in the early centuries of Christianity, by thinkers who wanted to reconcile the gospel with the best available philosophy.
Does this mean that cosmotheandrism restricts God to a philosophical principle? In a way, yes, in the sense that God is who he is, and cannot be who he isn’t. God even says I am who I am, so he is certainly not who he isn’t. But who is he? Does he have a nature? If so, he is “limited” by this nature, or is it his nature to be unlimited, i.e., Infinite?
Here we return to the apophatic world of Eckhartian paradox whereby God is limited by his own unlimitedness, or distinguished by his own lack of distinction. God is radically undetermined, so to enclose God — or his image (us) — in any kind of absolute determinism is actually to place illegitimate limits on both God and man.
For example, who says the future is written and even God can’t change it, because this implies change in God? Obviously there are countless examples from scripture that indicate otherwise, but to cite just one, how can God test Abraham if he already knows the outcome of the test? What is the point? In response to the test, God says, “now I know that you fear God, since you have not withheld your son, your only son from Me.” Now, I’m a simple man, but a straight reading of the text implies that God himself found out something that he didn’t know before the test: “now I know that you fear God.”
Now, there are two kinds of meaninglessness: chaos and disorder at one end, rigidity and excessive order at the other; or, randomness and determinism, respectively.
Of course, we know this isn’t a random universe. To the contrary, it is a shockingly ordered place, but to what end? The anthropic principle — at least the strong version — says it is ordered to us, of all people: the stronger versions of this principle maintain that the universe is the way it is because we are essentially its immanent telos: if the purpose of the universe is to give rise to intelligent life, then the laws of nature are precisely what they are in order to ensure that life and mind emerge and evolve. So we shouldn’t be surprised at the fine-tuning required for us to be here, because intelligent persons are the final cause, not a random effect, of the universe. If this is the case, then we ourselves are nothing less than the final cause of existence, recalling that first in intention is last in execution
That’s a heavy responsibility.
Nevertheless, supposing we are the immanent telos of the universe, this would seal us in an absurcular tautology unless we were in turn ordered to something transcending us. Man is intelligence, but not just any kind of intelligence, rather, an intelligence that transcends the material world and can thereby know truth. It is an open intelligence, open to intelligible being. But it is also vertically open, or open to the transcendent source of intelligence itself. Hence the latter must be the (divine) Telos of the (human) telos, so to speak.
Only in this way do we exit the tautology referenced above. We can indeed be King of the Universe, but where does this leave us if we aren’t subject to a higher authority? For again, human intelligence is not just horizontally but vertically open.
So, it seems that the final cause of the immanent universe is something like an intelligent being open to the Absolute. The point is, there is an “open anthropology,” in that man is essentially open to both Cosmos and Theos. But is the Theos open to us?
Hold that thought until tomorrow. This is a big rabbit hole. Meaning a big rabbit must reside here.









No comments:
Post a Comment