Saturday, June 10, 2023

Nice While it Lasted

To put it briefly, civilizations always die of a drying up of their religious sap, of an antagonism which grows up between the fundamental aspirations of the human soul and the frameworks in which societies seek to confine those aspirations. --Henri Daniel-Rops

Yesterday was one of those days in which I thought to myself -- and said to my son -- Life would be great if it weren't for fucking history

Conversely, the flowchart which we are proposing must be in but not of history; responsible for change, but itself unchanging:

not in time, but above it, and, far from arresting the progress of history, rather accelerates its course and the progress of knowledge (Maritain).

Naturally, if your map is accurate, you'll get to your destination more quickly. It is at once why the United States progressed so rapidly when it was grounded in such principles, and why it is now well into decadence and decline.

I once comforted myself by saying that What can't go on won't go on, not realizing that what can't go on is in fact the ordered liberty of a nation founded upon immutable principles of natural law; that fallen humanity not only could but did upend paradise, every time. 

And that was way before the Bidens got here. Barbarians are not only inside the gates, they are inside every institution and holding all the reins of power against which truth...

They don't need no steenking truth!

Thaaaat's right Petey. 

After all,

To be a conservative is to understand that man is a problem without a human solution. 

Now I have to comfort myself by remembering that

The truth does not share the defeat of its defenders,

and that

Today the conservative is merely a passenger who suffers a shipwreck with dignity.

For under the best of circumstances 

Civilizations are the summer buzzing of insects between two winters.

don't hear any buzzing, and if this is global warming, why is it freezing in here? 

In place of the vertical cosmic flow chart, we now have the static two-tiered leftist system in which

Leveling is the barbarian's substitute for order.  

Now, it's not just the news of the day, year, or millennium that has me reaching for the black pill. I also happen to be reading a history of The Church of the Apostles and Martyrs, which takes place during the transition from a 200 year period of unprecedented peace, order, and (relative) tranquility, to an eerily similar period of cynicism, decadence, and decline. 

Yes, people are always comparing every period to the end of the Roman Empire, but someday someone will be right. Let me find a couple of passages that made my ears perk up.

One paradoxical point the author highlights is that -- I'll paraphrase here -- we usually think of a revolutionary situation occurring during times of tumult, chaos, and uncertainty. 

However, the seeds of revolution require stability in order to be sowed and nurtured. Think of our own recent period of unprecedented stability, and the destructive ideas that were being propagated and imbibed right under the surface. A

doctrine needs a certain period of stability in which to permeate society thoroughly. 

Here is one of the paradoxes of human government: by establishing order and peace within its boundaries a society makes it easier for forces within its bosom which are attempting its destruction to act, despite all the precautions it may take to prevent this (Daniel-Rops).

In hindsight, obvious. Liberal democracy, insofar as it remains liberal, sows the seeds of its own eventual destruction by its liberality toward the progressive and tyrannical enemies of liberalism. Should have seen it coming, but it's too late now. 

I was one of those people who scoffed 15 years ago, when we first heard rumblings about the left's assault on the first amendment. "Never happen," I said. "Stop sounding so paranoid, you're just giving ammo to the left to depict the right as a bunch of unhinged conspiracy theorists."

I don't know enough about history to know about the inevitability of these things, but this guy writes with a great deal of authority and confidence. He's clearly smarter than you -- just look at him:

And he says 

the fundamental causes which, later on, from the beginning of the third century onwards, were to push Rome more and more rapidly towards the abyss were already present in the Empire's Golden Age.

History is obnoxious enough, but does it happen faster in our day? This is what Terence McKenna thought in his chemically aided visions, and it sounds plausible. 

Certainly affluence cuts both ways, and not just today, for it

was to cause the disintegration of Roman society in exactly the same way as, fifteen centuries later, it brought about the collapse of Spain, after the American expeditions of the Conquistadores.

All that gold flowing in merely enabled people to stop working and

the idle rich to spend riotously on dwelling-houses, food and drink and material pleasures of all kinds.

But enough about the Bidens.

Well, a little more:

Cowardliness and cruelty went hand in hand.... Men no more wanted to defend their frontiers than to till their soil.... Roman society was attacked in its most vital spot, at the source which sustains all societies; the structure of the family was shaken to the roots, and the birth-rate began to fall.

Fourth trimester abortion was rampant, "the 'exposing' of new-born babies acquired terrifying proportions," and divorce "became so commonplace that no one attempted to provide reasonable justification for it anymore: the simple desire fore a change sufficed."

This French snob makes rather sweeping claims, but again, I don't know enough to refute him: 

States have always shown themselves completely incapable of restoring their moral foundations once they have allowed themselves to weaken. The Roman authorities were far from being unaware of the peril, but their good intentions were absurdly useless, in view of the forces which were driving their society to ruin.

Oh well.

With good humor and pessimism it is possible to be neither wrong nor bored.

28 comments:

Gagdad Bob said...

Save us from Homo utopianus

julie said...

Life would be great if it weren't for fucking history.

One of the worst things about teaching my kids American History is having to say, so very often, "This is how it used to be/ was supposed to be, but since we now live in Clown World..."

julie said...

...what can't go on is in fact the ordered liberty of a nation founded upon immutable principles of natural law; that fallen humanity not only could but did upend paradise, every time.

It is a very hard thing to discover that when the Man was talking about the current prince of this world he was being perfectly serious.

Gagdad Bob said...

Z Man: "The world can go a long time without anything important happening, but then all of a sudden, we get a lot of history in a short period of time."

Good and hard, right in the brisket.

Gagdad Bob said...

Next week we'll essentially find out the extent to which America is still America, when they poll the reaction to this travesty. If people are neutral or in favor of it, I suspect America is finished.

julie said...

I'm cynical enough to think it already is finished. Next week will simply reveal - assuming that any polls are really accurate - whether it's murder or suicide.

Either way, the calls are definitely coming from inside the house.

Gagdad Bob said...

I guess I should be more black-pilled, but cheerfulness and optimism keep breaking through.

Gagdad Bob said...

Looks like AI is working on a vertical flowchart.

But can AI escape Godel?

julie said...

I don't know that I'd call myself black-pilled. On a personal level, life is good, plus it's hard to be that dark when you see prayers being answered so frequently. Just a little melancholy to know that the America I believed in may never exist again in my lifetime or my kids' lifetime.

ted said...

What kills me are the people who think once the system collapses, it will give birth to something beautiful. Not with our leftovers!

julie said...

Yuval Harari barely counts as being human. His AI Bible will probably feature commandments about eating the bugs.

ted said...

"A room full of Shakespeares on typewriters, will, in infinite time, end up beating their chests, swinging from trees and going ‘ooh ooh ooh’." - Darren Allen

Gagdad Bob said...

Perfect.

julie said...

Ted - as I see it, the whole point of there always being a Remnant is that until the final end, it will be possible for goodness - and good civilizations - to flourish on occasion. And I still believe that per capita, America has more of that Remnant than anyplace else.

ted said...

Perhaps the barbarians eat each other, and then we flourish!

Anonymous said...

Biden has a crooked drug addicted son. He also mishandled various levels of classified documents as did the last few presidents. If not illegal, the fact that a sitting vice president's son was getting paid off should be. He was not being paid for anything but his pipeline to his father.

I see references to impropriety re "Biden's justice department" implying that this was driven by Biden. However, I have seen nobody present any evidence of impropriety. If there was or any evidence of this, there should be an investigation and he should be impeached and all involved should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.

The latest Trump indictment is just that - an indictment. Trump should be presumed innocent and get a fair trial. However, having read the indictment (which I recommend - it is in plain English vs legalese and an easy read), it is hard to ignore the accusations which obviously all came from testimony of his lawyers and Republican associates. Fox legal consultant Johnathan Turley said "It is an extremely damning indictment." and "I know a lot of people have criticized [Jack] Smith for his background, but he's no Alvin Bragg. He's a serious prosecutor. The Alvin Bragg prosecution is a political prosecution. It is what Trump says it is. It is a weaponization of the criminal justice system, in my view. This is a different ball game".

I agree with Turley that the Manhattan DA Bragg prosecution is political and that this is quite different. Here is his full take - a worthwhile read: https://www.foxnews.com/media/new-trump-indictment-documents-whole-different-ballgame-jonathan-turley.

Randy said...

Speaking of unchanging principles, I'm curious how the Woke view the metaphysics of the Declaration; 'we hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights...'. So is the founding of the U.S. based on lies? Or just a useful fiction? Something we merely thought was true but now that we are enlightened...what then? And assuming this basis to be false, what foundation should we use instead?

Gagdad Bob said...

Really good book I'm reading about that very subject: Mere Natural Law: Originalism and the Anchoring Truths of the Constitution.

Randy said...

Sheesh. How many are you reading right now?

Gagdad Bob said...

Half a dozen. The usual, but at differing levels of difficulty. Metaphysics and theology by day, history, biography, and music by night.

julie said...

Don't worry, Randy, most of the long-time readers here gave up trying to keep up with Bob's reading pace ages ago ;)

Gagdad Bob said...

Besides, it's not like I remember any of it.

Anonymous said...

I'll bite, Randy.

'we hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights...'.

"Just not to freedom", the slaves all groaned. I guess the cool part was that many embraced Christ over the paganism of their ancestors, and then years later the Party of Lincoln would embrace both God and freedom mammon. So there's that.

But then I'm the old school kind of "woke", the kind where I know the negroes got screwed but don't wanna get all reparations about it.

Speaking of Gavin Newsom... Oh wait. I meant Chris Christie. Anybody see his accusing Kushner of getting those billions from the KSA in exchange for Iranian military secrets boxed up at Mar-a-Lago? Plus all Trump's 2016 campaign clips criticizing Hillary for her own classifieds carelessness as traitorous is making the rounds.

Guess I sorta got sidetracked. Would a real "woke" (the Disney kind) wanna take it from here?

Van Harvey said...

I'm less black pilled, than with "...After all,

To be a conservative is to understand that man is a problem without a human solution.
Now I have to comfort myself by remembering that

The truth does not share the defeat of its defenders..."

, and that by recognizing the Truth, you are rescued from the shipwreck - even if you go down with the ship, the Truth sails on, and to the extent you grasp it, so do you.

And besides, that is the flowchart.

Van Harvey said...

While I enjoyed reading Hadley Arkes' "Mere Natural Law: Originalism and the Anchoring Truths of the Constitution", much of the enjoyment came from the recognition that I needed to actively distinguish the Truth it contained, from the admixture of idealized falsehoods it also contained. The specifics don't come to mind at the moment, but the feeling of a constant jousting, does.

Good exercise, but....

Gagdad Bob said...

I'm only a third of the way through, but it is a little simplistic, failing to give proper due the enigma, flux, shadow, and contingency of this world of ours. Maybe too leftbrained?

Van Harvey said...

Gagdad said "Maybe too leftbrained?"

Going on the impressions of older memories, but as I recall there was a certain inappropriate (misplaced or mispositioned?) sense of certainty that ('fortunately!') facilitated his preferred conclusions, I think that does fit.

a_probst said...

Noplace-ian man?

Theme Song

Theme Song