Tuesday, January 17, 2023

Heading Back for Provisions

We can admit when we're wrong. Looks like we underestimated what we’re going to need for this journey, so we’re heading back for supplies. 

We’re still going to be traveling light, but there are certain provisions we can’t do without, and it might even be demented to try. Schuon thinks so, anyway: "To wish to replace reasoning by experience"

on the intellectual and spiritual plane, as the empiricists and existentialists wish to do, is properly speaking demented."

Besides, why toss out all the maps drawn by previous vertical explorers? Columbus still relied on maps, even though they become increasingly useless the further he ventured. 

Man is the rational animal, or so they say. If so, then reason is here for a reason, and we can only pretend to eliminate it -- or worse, become an "enlightened animal." Which, come to think of it, does happen -- I’m thinking of all those gurus who successfully detach from the world of illusion until the moment they’re surrounded by adoring females, and untransformed human nature takes its vengeance.

For Schuon, there is ultimately one religion because God is one and so is man. As is reality. But reality is also diverse, and as always, the question is how to reconcile the One and the many. 

It seems there are two ways to go about it: down and back, prior to the bifurcation of subject and object, or up and ahead to their transcendent synthesis. In Christendom
the absolute is unveiled in the person of God, who created other persons in order to summon them toward their deification (Clement).    
That’s from a book I just finished called Transfiguring Time. Not very good, but it will do. 

Long story short, time itself is a creature (i.e., created), and is one of the things assumed and redeemed by the Incarnation. Absent this, time is universally regarded by premodern peoples as tending toward entropy and deterioration. There is and can be no progress. Best we can do is stasis, or restoration of primordial paradise via various rituals such as human sacrifice. 

Yes, the left has always been with us: between now and utopia is always a thin membrane of genocide. The global warming cult has a long and exceedingly bloody lineage. As Clement says, "The modern myth of progress is a naive secularized form of biblical expectation of the Messiah.” 

Since time is part of our unredeemed nature, it cannot be transfigured except on a retail basis, one assoul at a time. But in the past two or three centuries “Western literature has been filled with a nostalgia for paradise akin to that of ancient times.” Here comes the New Age, same as the Old Age: both 
are animated by a nostalgia for paradise that leads them to consider history as a fall, preventing the return to the original condition, a return to the paradise that dwells on the other side of the material world, that is the obverse of the material world and of time....
The pursuit of practices that achieve an escape from time and the poetic magic of wonderland converge into a new atheism…
Good news/bad news: we can eliminate time, but man lives in time, so we can’t eliminate one without eliminating the other. So, we are in time. But we also touch the timeless:
It is indispensable to know at the outset that there are truths inherent in the human spirit that are as if buried in the “depths of the heart,” which means that they are contained as potentialities or virtualities in the pure Intellect: these are the principial and archetypal truths, those which prefigure and determine all others (Schuon).
Back to the first paragraph, these are the provisions we’ll be bringing along for the journey.

13 comments:

Gagdad Bob said...

Well, this is a coincidence: there's a great deal on the subject of experience vs. principles in this book I just began reading, The Irreducibility of the Human Person.

Gagdad Bob said...

Note to self: what is given to experience, but what -- what principles -- must be given in order for experience per se to exist?

Gagdad Bob said...

Who puts the fire into the metaphysics? Perhaps revelation is the poetry of metaphysics, which brings aesthetics into the equation.

Gagdad Bob said...

We're not asking for all that much, just the necessary structure of all possible realities.

julie said...

I mean, in the interests of full transparency it should be no big deal, right?

"To wish to replace reasoning by experience"

on the intellectual and spiritual plane, as the empiricists and existentialists wish to do, is properly speaking demented."


The irony is that people who wish to try must not really believe that what happens on the intellectual and spiritual plane is just as real and has consequences just as serious as any horizontal trip into an uncharted wilderness. I saw a headline somewhere recently that Aaron Rodgers is a big fan of ayahuasca, but now he keeps seeing a weird shadow man in a hat holding the corpse of a dead rabbit. Assuming that's true, on the one hand, sure, it's all in his head. On the other, it still has real and potentially lasting consequences.

Gagdad Bob said...

True, knowledge begins in the senses. But what if there is direct perception of spiritual phenomena via "higher" senses?

Gagdad Bob said...

It seems that the 1960s burned all the maps in a quest for the pure experience. How did that turn out?

Gagdad Bob said...

The song "Imagine" is the last word in map-burning.

Gagdad Bob said...

A romantic reaction against a sterile and disenchanted world.

julie said...

Should have clarified, I didn't mean to limit/reduce perception of spiritual phenomena to simple brain chemistry. Rather, I was thinking that by diving into something he probably wasn't really prepared for, with a little chemical assistance, who knows just what spiritual phenomena he opened himself to, as unsuspectingly as a toddler walking down a dark alley in the bad part of town?

And agreed, burning all the maps just means most people end up walking the wide, easy road, paved with virtue signals masking as good intentions.

I don't blame people for reacting against the sterile and disenchanting world - heck, that's how I ended up here - but having a few Unknown Friends and a useful set of guidebooks then becomes that much more important.

julie said...

Suddenly reminded of how Prager back when was instrumental back when, when he insisted on the importance of clarity over agreement. We live in a world that loathes clarity, because with clarity comes the possibility of proper understanding.

julie said...

*ugh - I have a new keyboard, it drops letters sometimes so I spend so much time fixing typos I miss the occasional poorly-formed sentence. At least, that's my excuse...

Gagdad Bob said...

Those comments weren't in response to yours, just me randomly wondering out loud...

Theme Song

Theme Song