Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Godmaxxing

Cosmotheandrism promises three times the metaphysical fun, since it gives us the transcendent Theos above, the immanent one below, and the relational one within, even while being the same One.

Josef Ratzinger — not exactly a lightweight — articulates the final Axiom of cosmotheandrism in affirming that personhood “must be understood as relation,” this because

the three persons that exist in God are in their nature relations. They are, therefore, not substances that stand next to each other, but they are real existing relations, and nothing besides. In God, person means relation. Relation, being related, is not something superadded to the person, but it is the person itself. In its nature, the person exists only as relation.

Bishop Robert Barron says something quite similar, describing a “revolution in theology brought about by the doctrine of the Trinity” whereby “relationality gains a much stronger place in the doctrine of God”:

Whereas the classical philosophers tended to make self-subsistence the quality of ultimate reality, and relationality a quality of created being, the doctrine of the Trinity compels us to say that ultimate reality is itself characterized by relationship.... Something like ‘being toward another’ belongs to the very essence of God.

A second consequence of this revolution is that “the division between unity (God) and plurality (creatures) is radically reworked,” which brings to mind Norris Clarke’s The One and the Many, the title alluding to one of the fundamental and enduring problems of philosophy. Well, problem solved, because the plurality is always in the oneness, and vice versa. The triune Godhead “has room for plurality without in any way negating divine unity,” showing that “something like plurality obtains within absolute being. The creative ground of all existence is, in its innermost nature, a looking toward, a being toward another.”

Plurality is therefore not a fallen state or contingent accident, rather, a divine perfection, so long as its intrinsic relationality is not forgotten. Moreover, in the triune Godhead, “something like speaking to, communicating with, belongs to the ground of reality.”

Which means we can check language off our list of mysteries, even while making it no less mysterious. For “It follows that divine communication or communication with creatures is not the beginning of divine communion and communication.” In other words, man, upon awakening to manhood, enters a conversation that is always already taking place. Language itself is possible only because the Cosmos is already a conversation.

Thus communication — or dia-logos — between Persons has literally been going on forever, so the Godhead never stops partaking in the joy of communication. Which perhaps explains why we ourselves enjoy vibing with others and being deeply understood. Communication isn’t just a tool we invented to trade information, rather, an echo of the eternal joy within the Godhead. We like being understood because we are made in the image of an Eternal Understanding.

Sub-cosmotheandrians think of relation in exterior terms only, like billiard balls bouncing off one another. However, with the triune Godhead we are talking about talking-about — about irreducible intersubjectivity and co-inherence. And this co-inherence goes all the way down, even unto a quantum realm that is likewise substance (particles) in relation (field).

With this metaphysical revolution the problem of persons is also solved, but again, without rendering our personhood any less mysterious. With any luck, I will always remain a mystery to myself, but now I at least know why: because I co-inhere not only with an Other who is within me (more on which as we proceed), but with the Absolute and Infinite Other(s).

Certainly this explains all the endless intelligibility packed into being and just waiting to be understood by us: it is “Because all things are made through the Logos, which is itself nothing but a subsistent relation to the other, coinherence, and not substance or individuality, must be the basic truth of things” (Clarke).

Because intellect and being are not externally related, but rather, coinhere, we have the great privilege of potentially understanding All There Is To Know About All There Is. We know we are intellectually related to a world that intelligibly relates to us, the question being — or no longer being — how this relatedness relates to a relational Godhead.

∞

Downshifting gears for a moment, man is both conscious (like animals) but also self-conscious, or conscious of consciousness. Now, this greater consciousness of which we are conscious goes to the Other alluded to above, for it is very much as if our conscious mind is in a dialectical relationship with some sort of infinite and inexhaustible ocean of consciousness. Not to pull rank on you, but this is the whole premise of Bionian psychoanalytic psychotherapy, which takes place between the poles of O, patient, and therapist.

At first blush it appears that with self-consciousness we are somehow above or outside the unconscious Other. But this can’t be the case, for there can be no strict line between consciousness, unconsciousness, self-consciousness, because each is but a mode of relational consciousness as such. As in the Godhead, they are at once distinct but inseparable.

Early psychoanalytic models posited a sharp division between conscious and unconscious minds. However, later developments emphasized the unity of a self that always partakes of both. We can talk about the two as if they are separate, but they can’t be. Rather, it is more like the yin-yang symbol of the Tao, in which there is unconsciousness in every act of consciousness, and vice versa. Nothing good ever comes of pretending our little ego could ever drink the ocean on which it floats.

Here again, the unconscious/conscious system is analogous to the wave/particle distinction in quantum physics: a particular thought is the precipitate of a wavelike flow of consciousness, in which our conscious mind is analogous to an ocean current, an explicate pattern within the implicate ocean. One might say we are children at play along the infinite shore where the waves of eternity break upon the sands a’ time.

Sometimes we can take an idea too far, other times not far enough. To be on the safe side I like to go with the former, because only if we go too far can we recognize the far enough.

Is it going too far to suggest that there is something analogous to the conscious/unconscious distinction in God? Well, supposing the Anthropos is the image of the Theos, then perhaps our conscious/unconscious structure is a distant echo of what goes on in the Godhead. For again, we are the way we are because the Godhead is the way it is.

Having said that, we must amend our understanding of the unconscious, because there is nothing UN- about it — as if it connotes ignorance or privation. Rather, it is more like a supra- or hyper-consciousness — like the total implicate field as opposed to a particulate point of individual selfhood.

The psychoanalyst James Grotstein elevated the concept of the unconscious from its unfortunate reduction to a mere cauldron of uncivilized desires and impulses to its true place as a mysterious “alter-ego, or ‘stranger within’ that shadows our existence in a most intimate, creative, and mysterious way.” Far from being “primitive and impersonal,” our Interior Stranger is not an it but a thou: it is “subjective and ultra-personal,” a “mystical, preternatural, numinous second self” characterized by “a loftiness, sophistication, versatility, profundity, virtuosity, and brilliance that utterly dwarf the conscious aspects of the ego.”

Which is precisely what we mean by the interior Other with whom we are always engaged: there is the local or surface ego dialectically related to the ineffable subject of being, and the creative resonance between them.

Grotstein appreciates the spiritual implications of this dialectic as it manifests in our moment-to-moment experience. Otherwise, it’s a little like living your life in a tiny boat and never looking around to appreciate the immense ocean upon which your vessel is floating, and of which it is actually composed, because in reality there is again no radically separate “ego” and “unconscious,” rather, a dynamic and fruitful relation between them. The unconscious is not unconscious at all, just not fully available to the ego; obviously, the totality of nonlocal consciousness cannot be circumscribed by the local ego. Indeed, Grotstein conceptualized the unconscious as a sort of “handicapped god”—

Please, the preferred nomenclature is a differently abled god.

Right. This differently abled “unconscious” intelligence requires a partner in order to accomplish its mission, which is very similar to McGilchrist’s analogy of the RH Master and the LH Emissary. The goal of psychotherapy is not merely knowledge of, or insight into, the unconscious, rather to establish a dynamic collaboration between the phenomenal ego — our conscious self — and the “ineffable subject of being” (O) upon which the ego floats and into which it infinitely extends.

Through a creative resonance between these two aspects or poles of our being, we are more spontaneously alive, creative, and “present.” It is like adding another dimension (or two or three) of both depth and height to our being, through which we become something that has never actually been, but is somehow more real than what we presently are. In this ceaseless dynamic, a new entity emerges, a “transcendent subject” that lives harmoniously in the dialectical space between our foreground self and the mysterious background subject that surrounds and vivifies it.

For example, Eckhart wrote that “In my birth all things were born, and I was the cause of myself and of all things... And if I did not exist, God would also not exist.” Just what did he mean by this? In fact, it was something similar to Grotstein’s description of the background subject of ineffable being. That is, the God that we can know cannot exist without our first “conceiving” and giving birth to him — God needs our assistance, or cooperation, to manifest herebelow.

In Eckhart’s understanding of the Incarnation, God is eternally taking on human nature, not just once, but for all time, in the ground of our being. Eckhart adheres to the ancient Christian idea that God becomes man so that man may become God — not literally, but in Grotstein’s sense of transforming the ineffable, nonlocal God-beyond-being into a local manifestation of his presence.

Think, for example, of the production of a dream, which for Grotstein “is a unique and mysterious event, an undertaking that requires an ability to think and to create that is beyond the capacity of conscious human beings.” “[D]reams are, at the very least, complex cinematographic productions requiring consummate artistry, technology, and aesthetic decision making…” They “are dramatic plays that are written, cast, plotted, directed, and produced and require the help of scenic designers and location scouts, along with other experts…” Who is this Dreamer who dreams the dream? It is a “profound preturnatural presence whose other name is the Ineffable Subject of Being, which itself is a part of a larger holographic entity, the Supraordinate Subject of Being and Agency.”

The point is, the unconscious Dreamer who dreams the dream possesses powers that surpass what our conscious minds can bring about. Moreover, the creative person is not only like this Dreamer, but essentially harnessing the power of the Dreamer to help dream creative productions, from poems to paintings to symphonies.

Some folks get — and live — this cosmotheandric way of life, such as the producer Rick Ruben or pianist Keith Jarrett. Jarrett is famous for his marathon flights into spontaneous composition, for which he takes no credit. Rather, “I believe in Music to the extent that it was here before we were…. I don’t believe that I can create, but that I can be a channel for the Creative. I do believe in the Creator,” who we might say is the differently abled God who needs a little help from Jarrett. Likewise Ruben, who has essentially compared himself to midwife assisting the birth of a hoped-for sonic miracle that is then offered to back to God.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

We Hope You Have Enjoyed the Show

As it's getting very near the end. Last January we gave ourselves one year to finish the Trilogy, so we apparently have only six more weeks to git ‘er done. 

Problem is, if our recent posts are on the right track, then done is something we can never git. This is actually a reflection of Axiom 6, ultimate vs. ultimacy, for we know going in that the best we can do is utter the last word (ultimacy) on the wordless (ultimate). The 99.9% of non-cosmotheandrians out there won’t get the point, but here is an example of someone who does, fella’ by the name of Gerardus van der Leeuw, who writes that “the religious significance of things” goes to “the meaning of the whole,” for which reason “no wider or deeper meaning can follow.” Therefore, religion — or in our case the meta-religion of cosmotheandrism — provides “the last word,” except that the meaning it conveys can never be finally spoken or understood. Rather, it is

a secret which reveals itself repeatedly, only nevertheless to remain eternally concealed. It implies an advance to the farthest boundary, where only one sole fact is understood: that all comprehension is “beyond.”

This is a perfectly clearobscuro expression of our shadowy existential predicament, situated as we are between the poles of immanence and transcendence. Meaning and knowledge are events within this space, as the “beyond being” is assimilated to being, in an endless dynamic. For cosmotheandrism the recognition of this dynamic is the “sole fact,” in the sense that it is the one thing we are always doing and can never stop doing, unless we put a stop to it ourselves via scientism, religionism, ideology, or just a general lack of curiosity.

Curiosity kills the cataphaticist?

Yes, in the sense that a relentless Curiosity is to apophaticism as is the Answer to cataphaticism, the former always transcending the latter. Still, there is no excuse for that pun.

But once you hop onto the vertical telovator there is no top floor, only an endless approach to, and engagement with, O, and is that so bad? It reminds me of a screenplay — say, the Big Lebowski — in which the plot is but the thinnest excuse for the revelation of more amusing and important things like character and theme.

The following has been sitting around on top of my good old desk for awhile. It sounds familiar, but I don’t remember publishing it. In any event, it is a thin excuse to elaborate on some of the timeless themes discussed above.

The Anthropic Tweenager: Betwixt Cosmos and Theos

Our distinguished competitors — the 99.9% — are happy to talk about the cosmos, but you will have noticed that this arbitrarily restricted concept not only cannot account for the living cosmologist, but eliminates him altogether. In contrast, Voegelin’s definition of anthropic being encompasses “the full range of the tension of existence toward the transcendental.” This dynamically open Cosmos contains but transcends the comparatively smaller cosmos posited by scientistic bean-counters. Note the implicit cosmotheandrism, in that Voegelin’s definition encompasses all of reality, including the animate, inanimate, personal, and Beyond.

Just as Eckhart prayed to God to rid him of god, we might say that the cosmotheandtist prays to God to rid him of the cosmos — i.e., the one that is disconnected from the Anthropos and Theos.

We don’t always quote David Bentley Hart, since he is so angrily misguided about certain prudential terrestrial matters, nevertheless he is within sniffing distance of a certain cosmotheandrism when he writes that “I might almost speak of two ‘supernatural’ poles — two vanishing points where nature either sinks down into foundations deeper than itself or soars up into an exalted realm higher than itself.”

This exactly parallels Voegelin’s definition of the metaxy, which is to say, “the experience of human existence as ‘between’ lower and upper poles; man and the divine, imperfection and perfection, ignorance and knowledge, the world and the Beyond,” etc. As for this latter — the Great Beyond referenced above — it is “That which is ultimate and is itself indefinable because it surpasses all categories of understanding,” this again going to Axiom 6, ultimacy vs. ultimate, the latter being the telos or “goal of the fundamental tension of existence” (Webb). In the fewest and shortest possible unwords, it is O (the ultimate) to which we are dynamically related (ultimacy).

Regarding this tension, our consciousness spontaneously differentiates the Cosmos into an immanent world and the transcendent ground. We exist between the two, like the radii between the center and circumference of the circle we have discussed. At the transcendent end is the supreme but ultimately undefinable reality “which may be considered either as the source or origin,” the Evermore that lures us into various forms of participation throughout history via religious experience and symbolization. Which makes Hart’s endorsement of democratic socialism all the more—

Let it go.

Right: no politics. Suffice it to say, it is always wrong to immanentize the eschaton: fallen man’s efforts to impose heaven always result in hell.

In any event, this ineffable Beyond is precisely what O is intended to symbolize, being that it is transcendent, unlimited, indefinable, and imperishable; it is at once source and ground, but beyond both. It is something the Anthropos seeks, or to which we are attracted, but this “lure” is ultimately located in O, for which reason we call it the Great Attractor. You might say that if you are looking for O, it has already found you. Note that symbols of O may range from theories of everything in physics, to metaphysical systems, to preliterate myths about the gods, to fully articulated theological visions of this ultimate source and ground.

However, in addition to these externalized models, there is also the matter of direct experience, for example, the mystic who returns with first hand experiential and participatory knowledge, which is not so much of O as in it. This is analogous to the difference between knowing all about water vs. diving into the ocean and swimming in it. Again, Voegelin’s definition of the Cosmos includes both: the immanent-scientific and the transcendent, symbolic, and experiential, but these necessarily take place in the same “in between” space where the Anthropos exists. We cannot actually become O, full stop, but we can certainly know of and participate in it.

In fact, we can’t actually not participate in it, given its necessary omnipresence. We may not notice this participation for the simple reason that we don’t generally notice things that are always present in the background. Dombrowski touches on this in his book Process Mysticism, for “what is always present tends to escape notice, as in spatiality,” which “is given in all experience.” Thus, the mystic is simply “someone who is explicitly aware of what remains implicit for the rest of us.” And Theos — or O — is implicitly present in all experience, being that experience as such is necessarily between the poles of immanence and transcendence.

For example both scientific and everyday knowledge presuppose “a higher kind of knowledge that provides us with a measure or standard.” So too does our appreciation of perfection imply such an implicit standard. Indeed, “our slow yet progressive efforts to know the world presupposes an omniscient standard that secures for us our strongest intuitions and knowledge claims” (ibid.).

Knowledge of truth is God making a house call?

That’s one way of putting it. Suffice it to say here that the existence of mystical experience implies “that either everyone is aware of God at least implicitly or no one is aware of God” (ibid.). All the peers in the world reviewing all the journals in existence must ultimately allude to a silent partner who is out of this world, presuming they are making an appeal to truth and to our ability to know it.

For Voegelin there is the Cosmos and our experience of it, the latter being the “luminous perspective” within the process of reality. This is the cosmic home from which we can never be evicted: the existence of the Anthropos is always between upper and lower poles: betwixt Cosmos and O, with degrees of knowledge and an implicit scale of perfection.

The shortest distance between two points is a straight line. But points are immaterial and dimensionless markers of position. A line between them reveals where they are, even though they’re not really there, a point not being a visible dot, for example. Applied to immanence and transcendence, these are like two dimensionless points at either end of the vertical line of consciousness. Here on earth the best we can do is acknowledge these two directional pointers without conflating them or reducing one to the other, much less denying their existence altogether.

The Cosmos spans vertically between the created and Uncreatable, the former being a re-verberation of the latter, i.e., a Word from our eternal Sponsor. In one sense creation is a miracle, but if the Theos principle is necessary, and if its nature is to create, then it is more of an inevitability. Also, real creators never stop creating. If Bach or Mozart were still alive, we’d have more masterpieces than we could ever consume, this being because in our logospheric Cosmos the Word never stops giving birth to words, melodies, theories, visions, and blog posts.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Creation, Relation, Distinction

As indicated in the previous post, cosmotheandrism follows in the footsteps of Aquinas in affirming that creation is continuous. However, we needn’t appeal to a 13th century padre in order to know this, rather, to a 20th century patent office clerk, in that we now know that the Cosmos itself is a creatively evolving event. Matter itself has an intrinsic history that must be taken into account in order to understand it: it is both in and of time, but also beyond time in the sense that it is embedded in the rationally intelligible structures that transcend it.

Nor does the Cosmos contain its sufficient reason within itself. To be sure, it is rationally ordered, but only to the extent that it is dependent upon, and thus related to, a transfinite ground or Gödelian meta-level. These upper storeys cannot go on forever, any more than causes in the past can go on forever without arriving at an uncaused cause.

Thus, at the top end of the upper vertical is what we might call the Unexplained Explanation, or O. We can never arrive at this final (ultimate) explanation, but it explains (via ultimacy) why explanations exist at all. We dwell on the subjective horizon that is always open to what is beyond ourselves, so we are at once limited forms open to the limitless. In cosmotheandric terms, being is always open to beyond-being, hence all the surprises, e.g., scientific breakthroughs, artistic creations, and evolutionary leaps.

Somewhat like AI, the Cosmos is ready to answer all our questions, but we have to furnish the correct prompts. Within it there is a multitude of orders, from mathematical to linguistic to genetic to aesthetic, so watch your prompts. If you restrict yourself to just one way of looking at things, the Cosmos will look back in only one way. Cosmic and anthropic rationality are bound inseparably together, not in any static, linear, or monocausal way, rather, in an open and dynamic manner: both Cosmos and Anthropos are events related to the Big Event of O.

Cosmotheandrism could hardly be less fashionable in a western world that has come to reject all metanarratives, which has resulted in the decomposition of reality into a tribal multiverse of subjectivism, relativism, and infrarational ideological pettiness. But it also rejects the other extreme of an absolute absolutism that imprisons us in some other guy’s static metanarrative, whether religionist or scientistic. Rather, one might say that there is an absolute metanarrative, except that it is always being written.

Have you ever watched a TV series in which the writers have written themselves into a corner? The writing might be quite clever, but it takes a lot of creativity to find a plausible way forward for the characters. Many of the narratives in which we enclose ourselves are like this, for example, the scientific narrative that ends up damming curiosity and blocking vertical progress, but also religionist ones that eliminate vertical options (e.g., predestination or divine omnipotence). Such restricted narratives inevitably generate anomalies, contradictions, and eventually absurdities, which are either ignored or papered over with ad hoc explanations.

As we have seen, both monism and dualism paint us into an existential corner that can only be escaped via trialism. For cosmotheandrism the One and the Two are always related via the Three. This is not just a Christian thing, for Lao Tse was certainly on the case in affirming that

The Tao gives birth to One. / One gives birth to Two. / Two gives birth to Three. / Three gives birth to all things.

If this isn’t revelation per se, then it is what I would call a pretty, pretty good guess. There are also echoes of this principle in Vedanta, what with the conception of God as Satchitananda, or Being-Consciousness-Beatitude. With a little metaphysical tweaking, it is not difficult to conceive of Sat as corresponding to the Absolute Father, or source and ground; Chit to the Logos-Son; and Ananda to the vivifying Holy Spirit coursing within and between.

But to repeat: we do not intend to use this or that religion to prove cosmotheandrism, rather, we want to look into how this or that religion is a more or less adequate expression of cosmotheandrism — in which God, man, and Cosmos are mutually related.

Here arises a Big Problem, for in the traditional view, we are related to God but God has no “real relations” with us. But as per Axiom 4, this is an irreducibly relational Cosmos that gives rise to irreducibly relational beings open to an irreducibly relational Godhead. The relations start at the top and filter down from there.

In Vedanta, God — or Brahman — is said to be an immutable “one without a second,” which is understandable. But for Christianity it is downright inexcusable to say that God is impassive and lacking in real relations, since that is precisely what God is: an eternally dynamic substance-in-relation. Here again the question is not whether Christianity can be reconciled with the nondualism of Vedanta, rather, whether there is an interpretation of Vedanta (or any other religion) that more adequately expresses the truth of cosmotheandrism.

For nearly all of our competitors there is a non-reciprocal arrow of dependence between creation and Creator: the former is utterly dependent on the latter, but the Theos is independent of everything. Anthropos too is necessarily dependent upon and thus related to Theos, but God does not return the favor because he cannot return the favor. If he could, then he wouldn’t be God, since God is necessarily unaffected by anything. As they say, no number of beings adds any more to Being, so God + world adds nothing to God. Cosmos cannot exist without Theos, but Theos can easily exist without the hassle of a Cosmos, much less the nuisance of the Anthropos.

This is all very neat and tidy, but is it true? Certainly not for cosmotheandrism, since our first principle is an Absolute whose immediate entailment is an Infinitude to which it is necessarily related. Traditionalists will sometimes use the analogy of the sun, which is unaffected by anything its rays happen to illuminate. Except in reality the rays are — obviously — still the sun. It is we who draw the distinction between sun and rays, whereas from the perspective of the sun — or God — they must be “not two.” They are at once distinct but of the same substance. And think of all the transformations of this substance as it embarks on an infinite journey away from its center. In this context, what is photosynthesis, for example, but an adventure of light into biology — a transformation of the sun into organisms? And supposing this has happened to the rays, one cannot say it hasn’t happened to the sun itself.

Our competitors should either stop using this analogy or get with the program and recognize what it actually implies: that life on earth is utterly dependent upon the sun, but that the sun isn’t as independent of the earth as you might imagine. Besides, in this post-Einsteinian universe, every time I do so much as a push-up I am essentially bench-pressing the earth. True, my gravitational effect on the earth is small but it is not non-existent. In reality there is always a mutual attraction within the field of gravity, and also in the field between Theos and Anthropos.

So God is a little attracted to you?

He must be, or he wouldn’t be God — at least not the God of cosmotheandrism. Besides, what is all this “God is love” business? Supposing he is, then, in the words of Bo Diddley, who do you love?

Whom.

Or better, Who, Whom, and Relation, none conceivable without the others.

Let me tell you a little story. It’s from the Rg Veda, which, in contemplating the beginning of the beginning, points out that there was neither existence nor non-existence.

What’s left?

Not even nothing, since that would presuppose something. So, “What stirred? When?” It seems that “Desire came upon that one in the beginning,” but I think you will agree that this is entirely ad hoc and explains nothing — that something that doesn’t even exist began to have desires? You can do better than that. Then again,

Who really knows? Who will here proclaim it? Whence was it produced? Whence is this creation? The gods came afterwards, with the creation of the universe. Who then knows whence it has arisen…. In the highest heaven, only he knows — or perhaps he does not know.

Well, we know, because creation is not something that ever began, nor is it something that ever ends — more like rays proceeding from the sun, which embark upon an ever-expanding journey across the Cosmos, meeting different fates along the way.

Do they ever return home?

No, because since they exist in a relational field, they never really left home anyway.

Theme Song

Theme Song